• ACRI

No Such Thing as a Consensual Search of a Phone


© Oleh Slepchenko - Dreamstime.com

Even if the police “convince” a suspect to allow his or her phone to be searched, this “consent” is baseless, and evidence obtained in a search without a warrant will be disqualified.


Searching a smart phone is different than any other search. We save vast amounts of personal information on our smart phones, including correspondences with family members and friends, as well as sensitive medical information. We also have access to many additional sources of information from our phones, including bank accounts, medical files, and dating apps. As such, searching a phone is a gross violation of personal space.


Searching a phone is also a highly sensitive matter; legally, such a search may only be conducted following a court hearing, it is not enough to obtain the “consent” of the person by taking advantage of the power dynamic between investigators and the individual being questioned. The police tend to obtain “consent” from the person being investigated to search their smart phone, and by doing so bypass the need for a warrant. This practice is simply illegal.


For more, see the position paper on a case that ACRI joined: A military court rejected evidence obtained by the Israel Defense Forces Criminal Investigations Department through a search conducted on a mobile phone without a warrant. The Criminal Investigations Department and the Attorney General appealed the decision, and ACRI filed an opinion on the case. The Supreme Court ultimately decided not to review the appeal, as the circumstances of the incident demonstrated that there was no consent to search the phone, and the fundamental question therefore became theoretical.



#RighttoPrivacy #police


Tel Aviv Headquarters

Nahalat Binyamin 75, Tel Aviv 65154
Israel

Phone: +972-3-5608185
Fax: +972-3-5608165
E-Mail: mail@acri.org.il

 

Jerusalem Branch

15 Yad Harutsim St, Talpiot, Jerusalem

Postal Address: PO Box 53262, Jerusalem 9153102, Israel

Phone: +972-2-6521218
Fax: +972-2-6521219

 

Nazareth Branch

Street Address: 3030/5 Rd.
Postal Address: P.O. Box 51070, Nazareth 16072, Israel

Phone: +972-4-8526333/4/5
Fax: +972-4-8526331

Terms of Use
Privacy
Accessibility
 
  • facebook
  • twitter
  • youtube
  • White Instagram Icon

Website design: Studio Lee&Tamar, Itai Raveh