top of page

Searing Criticism from Supreme Court on Failure to Protect Residents from Settler Violence

ACRI
13 minutes ago
3 min read



The violent settler with the military. The soldier is addressing a farmer attempting to access his land. Screenshot from video taken by a farmer from Wadi al-Fara'a
The violent settler with the military. The soldier is addressing a farmer attempting to access his land. Screenshot from video taken by a farmer from Wadi al-Fara'a

On November 15, 2026, the Supreme Court unanimously accepted the petition filed by ACRI and Bimkom – Planners for Planning Rights on behalf of Palestinian residents of Wadi al-Fara'a in the Jordan Valley, demanding that they be protected from ongoing violence by settler Moshe Sharvit and his associates. In a noteworthy judgment, the Court ruled that the State is violating its legal obligation to protect Palestinian residents from settler violence. The Court rejected the state's claim that its actions were sufficient and ordered it to take concrete enforcement measures to remove settler Moshe Sharvit from the residents' lands, prevent incursions and damage to their property, and ensure their free and regular access to their lands. 


The petition was filed in June 2025 following a prolonged pattern of violence, threats, harassment and property damage by Sharvit and members of the Emek Tirza farm, which was established illegally near the residents' lands. The petition described dozens of incidents involving incursions onto agricultural land and home yards, damage to crops and irrigation infrastructure, property destruction, herds being set to graze in cultivated fields, and threats against farmers. Sharvit had also blocked the access road with an iron gate, preventing the residents from cultivating their lands for approximately two years. In addition to the economic damage, the residents were left exposed to daily violence and violations of their personal security and their rights to property and livelihood, all while the military and police failed to provide protection.  


In some cases, rather than removing the attackers, the military removed the farmers from their own lands. There were also instances when Sharvit was accompanied by soldiers while he threatened residents and removed them from their lands and homes (regarding one such case, the State acknowledged that the military “erred when it conducted an operational activity together with a non-military party"). Following an interim order by the Supreme Court in March of 2026, the military issued orders prohibiting Israelis from entering the area. However, these orders were not effectively enforced, and the violence and harassment continued. 


In the judgment, written by Justice Daphne Barak-Erez, with the concurrence of Justices Ofer Grosskopf and Gila Canfy-Steinitz, the Court leveled unusually sharp criticism at the failures of the authorities. The Court held that the proceedings revealed "a bleak, disturbing and troubling picture" of inaction in the face of repeated violations of the law. Justice Barak-Erez emphasized that many incidents had not been addressed at all, and that even the minimal measures decided by the authorities had remained only "on paper.” As she wrote: "declarations are one thing and actions another." The reality on the ground demonstrates a lack of effective enforcement and, in practice, acquiescence to the violations of the residents' security, property, and livelihoods. 


The Court rejected the State's assertion that its actions were sufficient and held that the State was failing to fulfill its obligation to protect the Palestinian residents. Accordingly, the Court ordered the military to take effective measures to remove Sharvit and his associates from the residents' lands, prevent unauthorized grazing, and ensure the residents regular access to their lands and continued agricultural cultivation, including escorts and security where necessary. The Court further ruled that regular daily passage through the gate blocking access to the lands must be permitted, or that another solution must be found to ensure access. It also criticized the lack of effective police enforcement.  


The judgment emphasized that the situation was "intolerable" and expressed the hope that the judgment would serve as a "wake-up call" to the authorities. Justice Barak-Erez concluded: "The time to act is now." 


ACRI Attorney Reut Shaer stated in response to the judgement: "The judgment is a damning indictment of the ongoing abandonment of Palestinians to settler violence. For years, the residents have endured violence, threats, and dispossession from their lands, while the authorities have stood by and at times even assisted in removing them. The Court made clear that statements and orders that are not enforced are not enough. The military has an obligation to actually protect the residents, their homes, and their lands. We will continue to monitor the situation and demand that the Court's judgment be implemented on the ground." 


HCJ 66192-06-25 Zamel v. Commander of IDF Forces in the West Bank 

Attorney: Reut Shaer, Hila Sharon 


Judgement, December 15, 2026 (Heb)

For a full list of legal correspondence, see here (Heb). 

 

 

bottom of page